You're awfully wordy...
... it is much easier to contrive a "crappy" review than to fill out well constructed polls. You haven't seen single word feedback? or even single smilies as feedback?
No, it isn't. And no, I haven't. You're exaggerating.
Speaking for myself, I don't restrict my life to doing only what's needed. I find an ideal, and strive for it.
I don't care, and that's irrelevant.
Your suggestion already exists... but is naive in that people will not consistently format their posts in the way you have prescribed... Deleting posts or excluding members for not following your rubric is juvenile.
It's juvenile to want to set up rules and then penalize people for not following those rules?
There have been threads like this one, but no one's suggested doing exactly as I have. I tried to solve any issues I found in those with my own suggestion.
I'm not saying it WILL work but definitively saying it WON'T work is just annoying and unprovable.
You speak of discussion, but you have repeatedly dismissed EVERY other suggestion than your own... with fallacious logic and spite. Every other suggestion (except yours) can be abused, right? Your solution is simple and elegant and complete, right? Why even post?
In case there are more people who agree with me. The more people behind a suggestion, the more influence it has.
I do think that my suggestion has been the least prone to abuse so far, and any suggestion I haven't agreed with I've tried my best to explain why. I think there's more spite in your post than in any post I've made so far.
I've acknowledged that my solution isn't perfect twice, and you've quoted both those times:
I'm not saying it WILL work but definitively saying it WON'T work is just annoying and unprovable.
and
... Click whores and spammers will never go away, but with just a very simple edit to the sticky on that board, and everyone doing their part to help out even just a tiny bit, it really would make a world of difference.
Why did you create this topic if you'd already PMd an Admin?
Because they said it was a good idea and, like I've already said, if I got people to agree with me then maybe the change would implemented sooner.
[/b] I feel like you're trying to get the community to uphold whatever rules you set up. If nothing needs to be changed other than the sticky, how's that going? What actual progress has been made with this topic? If you want this to be just like reddit, why did you create an account at TPF?
Well, it's clearly not going, and that's why I'm still replying to this post. Progress is that this is the most viewed suggestion on this board, and hopefully and administrator will say something about it soon. I never said I wanted TPF to be like Reddit, I just think a system that works over there could be very beneficial here. You said you strive for your ideals, didn't you? That's exactly what I'm doing.
You know, for some who calls out others for using "fallacious logic and spite" you use an AWFUL lot of it.
Hopefully I helped with some of your misunderstanding. Sorry I left out some jargon, I didn't find it all that relevant.
