46
R&A Graveyard / Re: "Finished Tracks" Section Sucks rn
« on: January 17, 2016, 08:57:29 am »
The trouble with that kind of system is that people will just quickly post a couple of "COOL TRACK LOVE IT" messages and then post their own.
I think as the forum gets bigger the real problems with that forum will be (1) people who come in just to promote something, and (2) the sheer volume of posts. I think having a strict limit on posting there would be more useful than a feedback-for-feedback arrangement. For example, you have to have 50 posts on the forum before you can post there, and each user is limited to one post there per week.
Or maybe you could spend some (5?) of your "Honor" points to make a post there.
If someone's a valuable and helpful member of the community I think they deserve to show off a track every now and then, even if their helpful posts haven't been in the feedback forum.
I think as the forum gets bigger the real problems with that forum will be (1) people who come in just to promote something, and (2) the sheer volume of posts. I think having a strict limit on posting there would be more useful than a feedback-for-feedback arrangement. For example, you have to have 50 posts on the forum before you can post there, and each user is limited to one post there per week.
Or maybe you could spend some (5?) of your "Honor" points to make a post there.
If someone's a valuable and helpful member of the community I think they deserve to show off a track every now and then, even if their helpful posts haven't been in the feedback forum.