I think it's a fantastic idea, even if it's a bit of a raw deal for everyone involved.
The consumers don't get to use the product if they miss or pause a payment (but can continue paying later), but now have a route to get it that is not as cheap as piracy but still much cheaper than buying it outright and most importantly way easier and more convenient than piracy. It's the iTunes Store model.
For Splice and Duda/Xfer, neither of them are making a whole ton of money off of these, but they are now going to get sales that they wouldn't have previously had access to - people who have been holding off on buying it, and people who have pirated it and want a non-buggy, updated version. In the end, Duda will probably have made more money than if he had only offered it as a complete purchase.
Now I'm just waiting for them to add Nexus or Omnisphere.