Author Topic: Newtone is FL Studio is saying my melody is different than it is in piano roll  (Read 6108 times)

Dylan_Hanson

  • Sub Bass
  • *
  • Posts: 31
  • Honor: 2
    • hanson5325
    • dylanhanson0205
    • View Profile
Hey guys! Really need some help here with this track. It is supposed to be in D#Minor I checked the vocals with Newtone and they are in D#Minor however the instrumental is not. This is very frustrating because in the piano roll I have the intro melody (pads) going from D# to G# back down to D#. However, when I bounce this to audio and let Newtone analyze it this is not the case. It goes from G to C to G (basically it does not go from D# to G# to D# like I have it imputed in the piano roll). How do I fix this? Is it a problem with the actual sound itself? I only have the incorrect reading with pads... if it is a sharper sounding sound (like the synth in the drop or even a piano) than Newtone analyzes it exactly how I have it imputed in the piano roll. In other words it is an accurate reading. Hopefully this makes sense if not I will try to explain it more. Here is the track for reference.

https://soundcloud.com/hanson5325/were-all-about-having-fun
« Last Edit: April 06, 2016, 08:04:21 pm by Dylan_Hanson »

Dylan_Hanson

  • Sub Bass
  • *
  • Posts: 31
  • Honor: 2
    • hanson5325
    • dylanhanson0205
    • View Profile
Here is a better of of explaining it....

"So for some of my pad/organ melodies when I input them into Newtone which is basically just this plugin in fl studio that analyzes the pitch patterns.  It gives an incorrect reading (or maybe it's giving a correct reading who knows at this point as I have been spending all day trying to figure it out) Anyway the melody that I inputted into the piano roll is D#-G#-D# however when I input it into newtone it says the melody is actually G-C-G. This happens with almost all my pads/organs. If I use a sharper sound like a piano there is no difference in the reading. Even if I enter in a bass melody there is no difference. Do you think the issue is just the pad/organ presets themselves? Are they already out of key to the point when I input them onto the piano roll as D# it is actually at G? Is that even possible?"